Would That Guest Have Come Anyway?

Imagine you’ve signed up for a dining rewards program that charges you when its members eat at your restaurant. The first monthly report shows 100 visits. One guest discovered you through the program and booked on a Tuesday when you had plenty of room. Another has had table 12 every Thursday since before the program had a logo. Both visits belong on the report. The question I’d ask before renewing is how many of those guests would have come anyway.

After fifty years of running dining rooms, I tend to look at a promotion one service at a time. On a slow Tuesday, another party can make a difference. The room is open, the kitchen is staffed, and serving one more party costs little beyond the food and drink. On a Saturday with a waitlist, that same booking may take the place of one I could already fill. If I’m paying a fee either way, I want to know which service got busier and whether I had room for the extra business.

Let’s put some illustrative numbers to that report. Say the program cost you $1,000 for the month, and each genuinely additional visit contributed an average of $25 after the direct cost of serving that guest, but before program fees. At $25 a visit, you’d need 40 additional visits to cover the $1,000. If the program added 60, you’d come out $500 ahead. If it added 20, you’d come out $500 behind. The report shows the same 100 visits either way.

For your own calculation, pull out the invoice and look at what those guests ordered and what it cost to serve them. If you fund a reward or give a discount, count it once, either against what you keep from the visit or as a program cost. If a program booking displaces another paying table, allow for what you would have earned from the table you gave up. Once you know how much extra business you need, you can look at the dining room and ask whether you got it.

What Happened on Tuesday?

If I signed up because Tuesday dinner needed help, I’d put the program report beside the dining room’s total Tuesday covers. If the program counted more visits while we served about the same number of people, I’d look for familiar names in the reservation history. I’d also look at what else was going on. A seasonal slowdown could have pulled covers down while the program helped keep them steady. If covers went up, I’d give that number the same scrutiny, especially if we’d also started another promotion or booked a private party.

I’d want to know which guests were new to us and whether the familiar ones started coming more often. A first-time guest may have had us on their list for weeks, while a regular might have come in twice instead of once because of an offer. Reservation and point-of-sale records, where you can match them, help you see those patterns. Sometimes the records will give you a range rather than a precise answer. If you need 40 additional visits to break even and even the high end of your estimate is 30, you have enough to make a call about that month.

Will They Come Back Without the Reward?

A guest who finds you through the program may come back on their own, bring friends, or think of your place the next time someone asks where to go for dinner. That value can take months to show up. Meanwhile, if your Thursday regular enrolls and keeps coming at the same pace, you may be paying a fee on that check every week. Give both patterns the same time to show themselves. Over a few months, I’d want to see whether guests the program helped bring in came back and whether the fees kept following visits we were already getting.

A slow Tuesday can make a promise of more diners sound awfully good, especially when payroll is due on Friday. That’s when I’d read the agreement with a sample invoice beside it. I’d find out which checks trigger a fee, whether I can limit the offer to the services I need help with, and whether I can match the charges to my own sales records. I’d also check the minimum term, how much notice I have to give, and what it would cost to leave early. If the offer includes money upfront, that deserves a separate calculation, which I explore in What Will That Cash Advance Leave You on Friday?

I’d be wary of a deal that can charge me for my regular’s Thursday dinner and keep billing me for months after I’ve figured out it hasn’t helped Tuesday. Before signing or renewing, I’d ask the rep, “How can we tell which of these guests would have come anyway?” I’d listen for how they define a new guest, what I can check against my own records, and whether there’s a way to compare guests who received the offer with similar guests who didn’t. Then I’d agree on what we’re measuring and when we’ll look at it together.

By the time the next invoice arrives, I want to be able to say what happened on Tuesday.

If this essay resonates, Hospitality Between the Lines is just below.

Wes Zane

With more than five decades spent making people feel welcome, Wes brings a lifetime of experience in restaurants, wine, and hospitality to Foodie in Paradise. His writing explores the people, decisions, and experiences that shape modern hospitality.

https://www.foodieinparadise.com/about
Previous
Previous

What Will That Cash Advance Leave You on Friday?

Next
Next

How Long Does Wine Last After Opening?